Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Menu with Prices in New Zealand (September 2026)

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza New York pies Menu Prices

Every Sal's pizza is an 18-inch New York pie made with a slow-risen dough, a sweet tomato sauce and a NYC-style mozzarella blend. Each flavour is sold as a single slice, a half pie or a whole pie, so you can compare three price points. Simple pies like Cheese and Pepperoni sit at the bottom of the range, while loaded pies such as Buffalo Chicken and Chicken and Tomato top it. Staten Island is the plant-based option, made with Sal's cashew-based Nutzarella.

Pepperoni

Signature

from$7.50–

Cheese

from$7.00–

Nonna

from$7.50–

Buffalo Chicken

from$8.00–

Veggie

from$8.00–

Brooklyn

from$8.00–

Manhattan

from$8.00–

Fire Island

from$8.00–

Mushroom

from$7.50–

Chicken and Tomato

from$8.00–

Meatball

from$8.00–

Sausage

from$8.00–

Staten Island (V)

Vegan

from$8.00–

100 Pepp Black Garlic

from$8.00–

5 Boroughs

from$8.00–

Cupped Pepperoni

from$7.50–

Double Pepperoni

from$8.00–

Hawaiian

from$8.00–

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Sal's specialties Menu Prices

Sal's specialties are the sides that go with a pie. Garlic knots are the chain's signature dough tied into knots with crushed garlic and olive oil, and pepperoni wheels are dough rolled with pepperoni and mozzarella. There are twice-cooked Agria potato fries, breaded mozzarella sticks, free-range buffalo wings in 350 g or 700 g servings with several sauces, and a range of dipping sauces. Several sides are cheaper per piece when bought in multiples.

Sal's Signature Fries

$7.50–

Garlic Knots

from$3.50–

Pepperoni Wheel

from$8.50–

Buffalo Wings

from$20.00–

Mozzarella Sticks

from$11.00–

Authentic Dipping Sauces

$3.00–

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Desserts Menu Prices

Sal's keeps dessert simple. Zeppole are pieces of the pizza dough fried until golden, tossed in cinnamon sugar and dusted with icing sugar, served with vanilla custard, chocolate sauce or raspberry coulis for dipping. The other option is Ben & Jerry's ice cream in a small or large tub.

Ben & Jerry's ice cream

from$9.50–

Zeppole

from$5.50–

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Slice specials Menu Prices

Slice specials are Sal's single-person combos built around one or two slices. They pair slices with garlic knots, the house Legendary Sauce and a drink such as a Pepsi can or a Red Bull, and are priced between $14 and $22 on the official menu. They are the cheapest way to get a slice, knots and a drink together.

Sal's Famous

$14.00–

Charging Bull

$14.00–

Sal's Classic

$18.00–

Little Neck Combo

$22.00–

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Half-pizza & group specials Menu Prices

These bundles scale up from a half pie for one or two people to several whole pies for a group. The half-pizza specials combine half a pie with sides such as garlic knots, a pepperoni wheel, buffalo wings or mozzarella sticks, and sometimes a 1.5 L Pepsi Max. Group specials include half-and-half pies with knots, two whole pies, or three pies in the Tribeca Trio.

Grand Central

$37.00–

Queens Meal

$42.00–

Taste of New York

$52.00–

New York's Finest

$55.00–

Sal's NBL Steal

$45.00–

Broadway Bundle

$62.00–

The Perfect Union

$77.00–

Tribeca Trio

$115.00–

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Extra toppings Menu Prices

Extra toppings on a Sal's pie are priced in tiers, from herbs, sauces and hot honey at the low end to meatballs, sausage and chicken at the top. The prices listed on the official menu are for a whole 18-inch pie; the menu states that half pies are charged half price for the same topping. Swapping mozzarella for plant-based Nutzarella is free.

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Nutrition & Allergen Highlights

Quick picks from the full allergen matrix.Values are for the standard build of each item.

What Changed on the Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Menu

We started tracking this menu on 30 September 2026. Price changes will appear here after the next review.

How to Order at Sal's Authentic New York Pizza

1. Order in store at a Sal's pizzeria, by the slice or as a whole pie.
2. Order online through the 'Order Online' page on the official Sal's website.
3. Catering orders can be arranged through the official website.

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza Menu FAQ